Notices
Scion tC 1G Drivetrain & Power Engine and transmission discussions...
View Poll Results: Which One?
Turbo
63.04%
Supercharger
26.09%
Nitrous
4.35%
N/A High Powered
2.17%
N/A Bolt-ons
4.35%
Stock
0
0%
Voters: 46. You may not vote on this poll

WAR : Turbo v. Supercharger v. Nitrous v. N/A

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old Aug 5, 2005 | 10:45 AM
  #1  
GoSwim's Avatar
Thread Starter
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
 
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 261
From: Florida
Default WAR : Turbo v. Supercharger v. Nitrous v. N/A

Well everyone I decide to start this battle on the thought that good information would come out of it.

Turbo:
Turbo Kits Available/Under Production
- ZPI
- ScionSpeed
- Dezod
- Turbonetics and Greddy are rumored to go into production

Turbo kits start at about $3000 and at 6psi can produce about 240hp & 250tq.

Pros: Easily upgraded. Can produce large amounts of power. Easily increase power by raising boost levels. Can be very reliable with proper tunning.

Cons: High maintenance, heat, harder to install than S/C. Turbo lag. TRACTION.

Supercharger
Kit currently under production:
- TRD

Supercharger is estimated to cost $3200 and produce 200+hp & 200+tq

Pros: Toyota/Scion manufacture warranty. Reliable. Produces instant power. Less maintenance than T/C.

Cons: Harder to upgrade(must purchase new pulley & belt). Higher cost than turbo. Would probably void warranty if upgraded. TRACTION

Nitrous
There are no TC specific kits available, but universal kits available are:
- NOS, NX, Zex, Venom, Eddlebrock, Nitrous Works, ect...

Kits cost about $500 and can produce an extra 35+hp depending on shot used.

Pros: Least expensive way to produce power. Contrary to popular belief it's very safe when properly installed, (no it's not flamable and won't blow up like in F&F)

Cons: Power not always available. Must refill bottle. There is no room for error.

N/A
Bolt-ons available:
- Intake : Injen, K&N, AEM, ect...
- Exhaust : Injen, Blitz, HKS, ect...
- Header : Alphawerks, DC Sport, ect...
- Pulley : NST, Unorthodox, ect...

Major upgrades:
- Head : ZPI Stage 1

Sadly there are no major upgrades available at the moment (cams, valves, rods, pistons, ect...) and everything has to be custom made. The TC has a wonderful engine and has the possibilty produce big numbers.

Pros: Instant power, reliability, able to do little by little.

Cons: Very expensive, does not produce numbers as big as T/C or S/C

My Thoughts
I would love to build an N/A TC but due to lack of support it's more expensive usual. In the future I will be going turbo.
Old Aug 5, 2005 | 06:28 PM
  #2  
matty-tC's Avatar
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
 
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 2,045
Default

that's not all the turbo kits under development for the tC.

but turbo > * as far as power is concerned. not sure where you get the high maintenance thing from though.
Old Aug 5, 2005 | 07:24 PM
  #3  
Revilo's Avatar
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
 
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 588
Default

can you install header, intake, pulley and exhaust, then install the Supercharger?
Old Aug 5, 2005 | 08:22 PM
  #4  
reagulator's Avatar
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
 
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 946
From: Garden Grove, CA
Default

Originally Posted by Revilo
can you install header, intake, pulley and exhaust, then install the Supercharger?
everything except intake
Old Aug 5, 2005 | 09:28 PM
  #5  
Revilo's Avatar
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
 
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 588
Default

what about the intake? why it cannot be installed before the Supercharger?
Old Aug 6, 2005 | 02:42 PM
  #6  
tCarloRS1_0's Avatar
Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
 
Joined: Jun 2005
Posts: 87
From: MoCo, MD
Default

ok. a supercharger forces air right into the manifold. a cold air intake sucks in air and directs it into the manifold. if you have a supercharger, it's connected right into the engine. one, theres no need for an intake since the supercharger is already blowing air in. and two. there no way to connect an intake if the supercharger is there.
Old Aug 6, 2005 | 03:50 PM
  #7  
TimmyT's Avatar
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
Scion Society
SL Member
 
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 1,253
From: Sanger, CA
Default

I voted for turbo, but NA power is very nice. but VERY expensive if you want big numbers.
Old Aug 6, 2005 | 04:24 PM
  #8  
GoSwim's Avatar
Thread Starter
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
 
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 261
From: Florida
Default

Originally Posted by matty-tC
that's not all the turbo kits under development for the tC.
Then post them. The whole reason I started this thread was to get as much information out. If anyone has something they would like to add then go ahead.
Old Aug 6, 2005 | 04:27 PM
  #9  
05-RS1's Avatar
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
 
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 2,379
From: Houston, TX
Default

im torn between zpi stage 0 and trd supercharger =(
Old Aug 6, 2005 | 05:01 PM
  #10  
PoizentC's Avatar
Senior Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
 
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 333
From: Virginia Beach, VA
Default

turbo
Old Aug 6, 2005 | 10:33 PM
  #11  
kungpaosamuraiii's Avatar
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
 
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 1,726
Default

The S/C's airbox seems to sit right on top of the OEM airbox's posistion so it might be possible to get one of those cold air boxes onto it. If you wanted to be fancy I'm sure you can replace that whole tube and get a custom one to extend to the wheel well where a CAI would sit. I personally think the S/C with Umnitza's CAB (this is amusing to me) would be the best bet as it keeps the pipe as short as possible and has the advantage of a cone filter as opposed to the regular filter sheet.

I don't know if that's possible but to me it looks possible. I wouldn't know of any gains from any of the above but it's certainly a plausibility.
Old Aug 7, 2005 | 02:13 PM
  #12  
06tCguy's Avatar
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
 
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 347
From: 48101
Default

the supercharger won't produce instant power, it's cetrifugal, so it's gotta spin up to create maximum boost. N/A won't be instant power either, the whole powerband will end up moving upward..think 7k+. Turbo is the way to go..lag can be virtually eliminated with a proper sized turbo and piping and traction can be taken care of with a drag radial or stickier performance tire. I don't know where maintenance came from, and I don't know how u're talking about heat, whether underhood or needing an intercooler, but heatshields aren't hard to make, and are probably already available, and the install shouldn't be too bad, hardest thing would be tapping the pan for the oil feed line(assuming one would have to do that). and I'm not sure you'd want to run pullies with the supercharger..
Old Aug 7, 2005 | 04:37 PM
  #13  
matty-tC's Avatar
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
 
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 2,045
Default

Originally Posted by GoSwim
Originally Posted by matty-tC
that's not all the turbo kits under development for the tC.
Then post them. The whole reason I started this thread was to get as much information out. If anyone has something they would like to add then go ahead.
No need to get panties in a bunch. Give me 2 weeks and I will have the official post with all the information of a new kit
Old Aug 7, 2005 | 04:45 PM
  #14  
engifineer's Avatar
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
Scikotics
SL Member
 
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 9,731
From: Minneapolis, MN
Default

Originally Posted by 06tCguy
the supercharger won't produce instant power, it's cetrifugal, so it's gotta spin up to create maximum boost. N/A won't be instant power either, the whole powerband will end up moving upward..think 7k+. Turbo is the way to go..lag can be virtually eliminated with a proper sized turbo and piping and traction can be taken care of with a drag radial or stickier performance tire. I don't know where maintenance came from, and I don't know how u're talking about heat, whether underhood or needing an intercooler, but heatshields aren't hard to make, and are probably already available, and the install shouldn't be too bad, hardest thing would be tapping the pan for the oil feed line(assuming one would have to do that). and I'm not sure you'd want to run pullies with the supercharger..
Maintenance concerns are always higher with a turbo. A turbo runs very fast and very hot, so the lubricants have a chance to bake. The newer turbos are not as bad in this respect, but definitely more potential for breakdown than a supercharger.

I would say turbo for what is out. I would however like to see a good roots or screw type SC come out for comparison though. The linear action of these designs would be great... but there are none....
Old Aug 7, 2005 | 11:03 PM
  #15  
Revilo's Avatar
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
 
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 588
Default

Originally Posted by tCarloRS1.0
ok. a supercharger forces air right into the manifold. a cold air intake sucks in air and directs it into the manifold. if you have a supercharger, it's connected right into the engine. one, theres no need for an intake since the supercharger is already blowing air in. and two. there no way to connect an intake if the supercharger is there.
what about if i have the Weapon R intake? i can keep it if i install the Supercharger?
If not, i need to install the OEM Air Box? but why? The Weapon R Intake does the same work of the OEM Air Box, only with better air flow, right?
Old Aug 8, 2005 | 03:04 AM
  #16  
teksno's Avatar
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
Scinergy
 
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 256
From: Warner Robins, GA
Default

there is no replacement for displacement...

but take that same displacement and go forced induction... now you are talking insane numbers.
Old Aug 8, 2005 | 03:58 AM
  #17  
GoSwim's Avatar
Thread Starter
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
 
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 261
From: Florida
Default

Originally Posted by 06tCguy
the supercharger won't produce instant power, it's cetrifugal, so it's gotta spin up to create maximum boost. N/A won't be instant power either, the whole powerband will end up moving upward..think 7k+. Turbo is the way to go..lag can be virtually eliminated with a proper sized turbo and piping and traction can be taken care of with a drag radial or stickier performance tire. I don't know where maintenance came from, and I don't know how u're talking about heat, whether underhood or needing an intercooler, but heatshields aren't hard to make, and are probably already available, and the install shouldn't be too bad, hardest thing would be tapping the pan for the oil feed line(assuming one would have to do that). and I'm not sure you'd want to run pullies with the supercharger..
1. Your right it does have to spin up and gradually get to maximum boost, but some power is there instantly.

2. N/A same thing. You're not going to have 200hp as soon as you step on it but some power is there.

3. I 100% agree with you on turbo lag. With proper tunning it can be virtually eliminated. (I had it written on my original post but the site stalled when I turned it in everything got erased , so what your seeing was quickly retyped and no where near as good)

4. Traction is going to be a problem no matter what. It can be helped but it's a FWD cars biggest enemy.

5. A turbo runs hot and although you can find ways to cool it theres no denying it's hot. This is were the extra maintenance comes from. You'll need a turbo timer and you should change your oil more often.

6. I'm not complaining that a turbo is hard to install, it's just harder to install.

7. The S/C runs on a pulley. If you want more boost you have to change it.

Originally Posted by matty-tC
No need to get panties in a bunch. Give me 2 weeks and I will have the official post with all the information of a new kit
I didn't mean to come off as upset. It's cool! Keep us informed on the new kit.

Originally Posted by engifineer
Maintenance concerns are always higher with a turbo. A turbo runs very fast and very hot, so the lubricants have a chance to bake. The newer turbos are not as bad in this respect, but definitely more potential for breakdown than a supercharger.
That's exactly what I meant. Thanks for posting.
Old Aug 8, 2005 | 04:17 AM
  #18  
06tCguy's Avatar
Senior Member
10 Year Member
5 Year Member
SL Member
 
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 347
From: 48101
Default

a positive displacement blower would be pretty nice, especially a twin-screw, a linear torque curve would be beautiful, and more predictible, as opposed to hitting boost and blowing the tires off all of a sudden. in reference to the pulley, I was talking about a aftermarket crank pullies or accessory pullies, not supercharger pullies.




All times are GMT. The time now is 06:41 AM.