View Poll Results: Piston WHP threshold?
Voters: 21. You may not vote on this poll
Stock Piston - WHP Threshold
Originally Posted by johnhawkins
How much WHP can the stock pistons hold????
I hear from numerous people that the stock rods are weak but how about the pistons?
A lower comression would be ideal, but are they necessary to replace?
I hear from numerous people that the stock rods are weak but how about the pistons?
A lower comression would be ideal, but are they necessary to replace?
The compression ration has nothing really to do with building a forced induction system, but you will need to know what kind of fuel you will be using in order to run an appropriate compression ratio... I have built several turbo cars using 11.0-1 pistons... only problem is there will be massive torque and you will spin tires all day long and you will be running some kind of injection or e85 for everyday driving... If you have e85 readily available, I say go with highier compression pistons and you will see some amazing spool. If I ever burn a piston (which hopefully wont happen) I will be going to a higher compression piston and running e85 on 20+psi daily.
Remember when you run forced induction you are effectively raising the compression by adding more air... So if you run 15psi on 8.5-1 pistons thats is roughly the same as running 10 on 9.5-1 pistons.
Currently I run 16psi on a 60-1 without a tune daily with no issues... But im sure that because the ecu is dumpin all the gas it can into the cylinders whenever I barely tap the gas.
There is a difference in your comparison. Effective compression ratio with 9.6:1 pistons 10psi boost = 16.1:1 and 8.5:1 pistons 15psi = 17.2:1. you will have to retard ignition timing even more on the 15psi setup to decrease the chance of detonation. Are you saying you were running 16psi on a stock block is so this would put you at 20.1:1 effective compression ratio which means you would have to run race fuel or retard the ignition timing very extreme to prevent detonation? Are you running any engine managment on your 16psi and has it ever been tuned, what size injectors, what fuel are you running?
Originally Posted by toyota_scion_tc
There is a difference in your comparison. Effective compression ratio with 9.6:1 pistons 10psi boost = 16.1:1 and 8.5:1 pistons 15psi = 17.2:1. you will have to retard ignition timing even more on the 15psi setup to decrease the chance of detonation. Are you saying you were running 16psi on a stock block is so this would put you at 20.1:1 effective compression ratio which means you would have to run race fuel or retard the ignition timing very extreme to prevent detonation? Are you running any engine managment on your 16psi and has it ever been tuned, what size injectors, what fuel are you running?
There are two ways to reduce knock, (A) pull timing, or (B) add enough fuel to buffer the chemical reaction... Buffering the chemical reaction slows the combustion process thereby eliminating knock.... Usually people add some sort of injection to achieve this, I just prefer not to.
The higher octane rated fuels also do the same thing. The higher octane rating makes the air/fuel mixture burn slower (in some cases with less fuel) but with more fuel. The higher octane rated fuels have a lower level of chemical potential energy which means you will need more of that fuel to achieve the same amount of resultant thermal energy from the reaction... This is very evident with cars running on e85 or straight alcohol. These cars require more fuel volume requiring higher flowing injectors and fuel pumps.
Originally Posted by toyota_scion_tc
That maybe true but you would have to retard the ignition timing a lot to run 12 pounds on 93 not to mention its not efficient. Boosted car will run retarded ignition timing to start with and still be efficient but there is a threshold on maximum boost with engines compresson on pump gas and anything more than 10-11lbs on 9.6:1 is pushing the limit. I will find the calculation and post it just give some time to.
I am still searching but this is from Procharger.com
"Compression ratio:
For pump gas (91-93 octane) applications, a compression ratio of 8.5:1 to 9:1 is recommended for boost levels of 8-10 psi. Higher octane fuel will allow you to run higher boost levels, approximately 1 psi for every 2 points of octane. To determine the maximum boost level for your compression ratio (using pump gas), refer to the enclosed compression ratio chart."
I am still searching but this is from Procharger.com
"Compression ratio:
For pump gas (91-93 octane) applications, a compression ratio of 8.5:1 to 9:1 is recommended for boost levels of 8-10 psi. Higher octane fuel will allow you to run higher boost levels, approximately 1 psi for every 2 points of octane. To determine the maximum boost level for your compression ratio (using pump gas), refer to the enclosed compression ratio chart."
Originally Posted by toyota_scion_tc
makes more sense now bc you said untuned so it has some sort of tune just not by a shop, bigger injectors help, already broke into the engine to lower compression.
Been running 360 WHP on pump gas everyday for almost 2 years. 100% stock motor. Take it to track during summer many times, run more boost at around 440 WHP with VP race fuels no problems at all. Again, all stock motor. These things are surprisingly strong. Keep in mind this is all on standalone Hydra ECU. I doubt it would have survived this long with a piggyback.
Originally Posted by SoFloTC
umm.. ive seen a couple local tc's on 18+ lbs with stock fuel system.. and easily over 400..
ya i will get the list of mods for u 2morrow. my tuner did his car.. they raised the boost to i think 22 lbs for a little and then raped a c6 z06 lol. hes fully built.. pnp head springs retainers etc., with full internals + sleeved with 800cc injectors
Originally Posted by johnhawkins
Hey Paul,
I know you guys sell the FIC with your kit.
Will you guys do a tune with the Ultimate for me?
I want to take advatage of the 2 step launch control.
I know you guys sell the FIC with your kit.
Will you guys do a tune with the Ultimate for me?
I want to take advatage of the 2 step launch control.
Originally Posted by cburglb34
Originally Posted by johnhawkins
hey man - lol - motor not blown jsut beat spark plugs and loose coil pack---must have been from the hi rev---but I did order an 05 block from dezodwest that ship tomorrow....im scared now that I will blow my motor so im building one to swap in april---i dont plan on running rediculous boost but prob like 13-15 with a small turbo......nothing voer 400whp...on the other thread(forgot which on and who) some one stated that the pistons are good for about 400whp....so i was goin to see if it was worth the money to even get upgraded pistons if im not going to surpass te 400whp mark
just buy the pistons and rods, its like using a condom
So - can someone list out what the minimal mods to "safely" raise the redline about 1k? Ive been looking through a lot of posts and many people were saying that sleeving should be introduced at 400whp. Are there different kinds of sleeve jobs that make sense for lower hp setups (300-350whp)? Safety is more the key w/ me. Nothing would be worse then rebuilding an engine and blowing a hole in it. I think the going price on a used head is $300 and there seem to be many camry/tc heads out there.
With the goal of under 340whp - are there any parts that people would say "surely do not have to be replaced"? I haven't heard much about things that do not need to be done, but a lot of people are just throwing parts at engines through pure guessing.
With the goal of under 340whp - are there any parts that people would say "surely do not have to be replaced"? I haven't heard much about things that do not need to be done, but a lot of people are just throwing parts at engines through pure guessing.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
B_Real45
PPC: Engine / Drivetrain
1
Feb 23, 2015 07:33 PM
darkshadowofxdeath
Scion tC 1G Owners Lounge
2
Dec 3, 2014 06:59 PM















