Atheist vs Theist (Debate)
Senior Member




Scion Justice League of America
SL Member
Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 5,594
From: Portland, Oregon
I like all the what ifs.... LoL...
I still think that ultimately, you must deal with my last post... it's still quiet a significant fight with logic to grab onto order from chaos... and reason from random... (simple terms, but insanely complex science, and quite possibly, unsolvable science, which you've really posted some good thoughts about, and conceeded a bit on the fact that there is an idea that the answers are not there, and may be in the future... although... they may not be as well, within that line of logic)
There are a lot of what if's... and I like them as well...
What if your right? Ok...no biggie, a bit of lost time and a few human creatures maybe are inconvienienced due to the "Wacky" Christians around, no big deal in the scheme of things... after all, humanity is not even a blip in the immensity of time, so all possible hurt or pursecution as the result of politics or man, isn't significant at all universally, as it's just human animals upon human animals and ultimately matter to be reused down the timeline.
What if I'm right? Uh, Oh... well, then it'd time to be a little humble and admit, that sometime we did't have the answers, and sometimes all the answers aren't there...
We both realize a bit that we fill in the gaps as much as we can, but, in the end... with Atheism and Theism.... IT ALL COMES DOWN TO FAITH.
I see order all around me, and almost infinate complexity in design... The faith that's required of me to believe that it is all the byproduct of randomness and chaos is too significant of a jump for me... It's not consistent with what I see around me, or what I've experienced in my life. Trust me, in my world travels, there must have been an innumerable amount of coincidence in the incredible things I've seen worldwide, and some flippin' amazing examples of the power of prayer... rack it up to coincidence on your side, but in my shoes... and I'm pretty dang skeptical of things, You'd never convince me there's NOT something outside this natural world that can effect the hearts of humanity, and the fate of lifes....
I see it everyday in my work with the homeless, call it delusion, or misguided hope, but I see every single day what secular society and the world around us does to people... and I've seen what true Christianity does to people... and the dynamic experience supports and builds my worldview.
I don't see HOPE in atheism... I don't see a FULLFILLING purpose... Living my life just to help others have a good temporary existance, just to become dust and cease to exist seems to show some insane insignificance to life... my only significance is helping others, and in return, helping myself better tolerate the short time of existance I have... How empty, small, and sad that must be.... I can't, even in fully distancing myself from the ideals of faith, gather how that appeals to the heart of man.... I understand fully how Christianity DOESN'T appeal in many ways (Due to some pretty significant absolutes in the moral areas), and fully see many individual's passionate opposition of it... but,
I've yet to have an atheist sell me on the true hope and fullfilling appeal of that worldview...
In the ideals of faith and God, at least I personally can compliment what I see in the world in regards to design and order, I can account for man's true purpose and the origins of morality, and I can account for the value of human life, over any other...
I sincerely believe that someone with an honest heart, and a mind free from the stereotypes and perversions of what Christian doctrine is, can see a significant value, a sincere truth, and a worldview is consistent with what we see in around us, not only in the nature of the world and it's intricate design, but the nature of man, in our own pure selfishness....
I've studied the Bible and brought many, if not all of the stated "Inconsistancies" and "Contradictions" in front of myself in my own study, and in front of people I trust, both from within the faith, and those in opposition to the faith, and can rest solidly in the truth, based on biblical context, knowledge of culture, and knowledge of historical and biblical accounts from a cultural perspective. There's a lot to delve into, but realise that a collection of books written across many many years was written primarily to people within that historical and cultural timeline, and that we must take time to distance ourselves from how we are used to interpreting history and literal account, and adopt the mindset and perspective of the individuals written to in that time frame... it's one SMALL part of Biblical theology that is almost always left out of the "Contradictory Bible Sites"... Imagine if, say, for arguements sake, 2000 years ago, the Bible was written in the language or way we interpret history today, it'd be useless and foreign to the people.... but, since we have history, and the knowledge of the culture and way history was shared and interpreted from that timeframe, we can, with true research, effort, and diligence, understand the message, filtered to our own way of seeing things... That paragraph is only a BRIEF description of one small part of the study of biblical text, when addressing possible "inconsistancies"... again, why focusing on simple and "Easy" answers regarding them is futile.
I don't truely believe there is a sincerity in really wanting to account for those items addressed by individuals in opposition to the faith, but I see more, based on reading this, and speaking to hundreds of people about faith, that most people just want to share opposition, cause it's easy, and provides a sense of security and the illusion of correctness... but when the rubber meets the road... are wholly uninterested in spending the time and effort to truely understand...
Once again, the time, study, and respect for history, biblical writings, and what I'd expect from an individual discussing it, ,cannot be controlled here enough to have me trust anyone to go through and discuss many of the issues brought here in depth...
Which, I think shows my STRONG respect for the process of discussing and sharing faith, and could equally show many individual's naivity, in thinking that this envirnment would be fair to either ideal, or even begin to reach the depth of knowledge to defend and account for atheist or theist ideals.
From here, all I see is going around in circles.... have at it... I got faithful work to do
I still think that ultimately, you must deal with my last post... it's still quiet a significant fight with logic to grab onto order from chaos... and reason from random... (simple terms, but insanely complex science, and quite possibly, unsolvable science, which you've really posted some good thoughts about, and conceeded a bit on the fact that there is an idea that the answers are not there, and may be in the future... although... they may not be as well, within that line of logic)
There are a lot of what if's... and I like them as well...
What if your right? Ok...no biggie, a bit of lost time and a few human creatures maybe are inconvienienced due to the "Wacky" Christians around, no big deal in the scheme of things... after all, humanity is not even a blip in the immensity of time, so all possible hurt or pursecution as the result of politics or man, isn't significant at all universally, as it's just human animals upon human animals and ultimately matter to be reused down the timeline.
What if I'm right? Uh, Oh... well, then it'd time to be a little humble and admit, that sometime we did't have the answers, and sometimes all the answers aren't there...
We both realize a bit that we fill in the gaps as much as we can, but, in the end... with Atheism and Theism.... IT ALL COMES DOWN TO FAITH.
I see order all around me, and almost infinate complexity in design... The faith that's required of me to believe that it is all the byproduct of randomness and chaos is too significant of a jump for me... It's not consistent with what I see around me, or what I've experienced in my life. Trust me, in my world travels, there must have been an innumerable amount of coincidence in the incredible things I've seen worldwide, and some flippin' amazing examples of the power of prayer... rack it up to coincidence on your side, but in my shoes... and I'm pretty dang skeptical of things, You'd never convince me there's NOT something outside this natural world that can effect the hearts of humanity, and the fate of lifes....
I see it everyday in my work with the homeless, call it delusion, or misguided hope, but I see every single day what secular society and the world around us does to people... and I've seen what true Christianity does to people... and the dynamic experience supports and builds my worldview.
I don't see HOPE in atheism... I don't see a FULLFILLING purpose... Living my life just to help others have a good temporary existance, just to become dust and cease to exist seems to show some insane insignificance to life... my only significance is helping others, and in return, helping myself better tolerate the short time of existance I have... How empty, small, and sad that must be.... I can't, even in fully distancing myself from the ideals of faith, gather how that appeals to the heart of man.... I understand fully how Christianity DOESN'T appeal in many ways (Due to some pretty significant absolutes in the moral areas), and fully see many individual's passionate opposition of it... but,
I've yet to have an atheist sell me on the true hope and fullfilling appeal of that worldview...
In the ideals of faith and God, at least I personally can compliment what I see in the world in regards to design and order, I can account for man's true purpose and the origins of morality, and I can account for the value of human life, over any other...
I sincerely believe that someone with an honest heart, and a mind free from the stereotypes and perversions of what Christian doctrine is, can see a significant value, a sincere truth, and a worldview is consistent with what we see in around us, not only in the nature of the world and it's intricate design, but the nature of man, in our own pure selfishness....
I've studied the Bible and brought many, if not all of the stated "Inconsistancies" and "Contradictions" in front of myself in my own study, and in front of people I trust, both from within the faith, and those in opposition to the faith, and can rest solidly in the truth, based on biblical context, knowledge of culture, and knowledge of historical and biblical accounts from a cultural perspective. There's a lot to delve into, but realise that a collection of books written across many many years was written primarily to people within that historical and cultural timeline, and that we must take time to distance ourselves from how we are used to interpreting history and literal account, and adopt the mindset and perspective of the individuals written to in that time frame... it's one SMALL part of Biblical theology that is almost always left out of the "Contradictory Bible Sites"... Imagine if, say, for arguements sake, 2000 years ago, the Bible was written in the language or way we interpret history today, it'd be useless and foreign to the people.... but, since we have history, and the knowledge of the culture and way history was shared and interpreted from that timeframe, we can, with true research, effort, and diligence, understand the message, filtered to our own way of seeing things... That paragraph is only a BRIEF description of one small part of the study of biblical text, when addressing possible "inconsistancies"... again, why focusing on simple and "Easy" answers regarding them is futile.
I don't truely believe there is a sincerity in really wanting to account for those items addressed by individuals in opposition to the faith, but I see more, based on reading this, and speaking to hundreds of people about faith, that most people just want to share opposition, cause it's easy, and provides a sense of security and the illusion of correctness... but when the rubber meets the road... are wholly uninterested in spending the time and effort to truely understand...
Once again, the time, study, and respect for history, biblical writings, and what I'd expect from an individual discussing it, ,cannot be controlled here enough to have me trust anyone to go through and discuss many of the issues brought here in depth...
Which, I think shows my STRONG respect for the process of discussing and sharing faith, and could equally show many individual's naivity, in thinking that this envirnment would be fair to either ideal, or even begin to reach the depth of knowledge to defend and account for atheist or theist ideals.
From here, all I see is going around in circles.... have at it... I got faithful work to do
Senior Member




Scion Justice League of America
SL Member
Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 5,594
From: Portland, Oregon
BTW - If you don't wan't to read a lot, or talk about ideals and want to stomp on me in a game, go here! It's a heck of a lot more fun that reading this stuff, and talking worldviews
Show me the scientific and rational mind in this game!
https://www.scionlife.com/forums/vie...r=asc&&start=0
Show me the scientific and rational mind in this game!
https://www.scionlife.com/forums/vie...r=asc&&start=0
^^^^
that game was hard. gave up on it
The current universe may not be the only, or the first to exist. This could be the billionth go around for us for all we know, covering a span of a googleplex years.
ok, stiil havent answered the question.
where did the FIRST anything come from. before your aliens, alternate universes, and other so called logical theories took place.
you still havent established any beginning to your theories.
still looking for this evidence. please dont send me googled links to bible contradictions because they are laughable and discredited.
you dont believe in God, but you tell me what limitations he has, and the limitations that we have about understanding him. you tell me that in death i wont understand God when you dont think He exists. why?
what do mean by "if he is what he is." there are so many interpretations of God or a god. which one do you mean? the only one that matters is the true God. and He explains how we unable to understand Him fully, but not "beyond all conception."
your kidding right?
dont put "what ifs" and expect results that matter.
ive always believed this also. to be atheist requires much more faith than to not. it you can believe that everything came from absolutely nothing, then you've got to have more faith than anyone who believes otherwise
that game was hard. gave up on it
Originally Posted by backseatchris
The current universe may not be the only, or the first to exist. This could be the billionth go around for us for all we know, covering a span of a googleplex years.
where did the FIRST anything come from. before your aliens, alternate universes, and other so called logical theories took place.
you still havent established any beginning to your theories.
Originally Posted by backseatchris
An atheist can provide evidence against many things in modern, established religion. so.
Originally Posted by backseatchris
What i am saying is that anything anyone [says] in this universe about god would have to be completely false. If he is what he is, then he is beyond all conception of man. Not even in death would a human understand.
what do mean by "if he is what he is." there are so many interpretations of God or a god. which one do you mean? the only one that matters is the true God. and He explains how we unable to understand Him fully, but not "beyond all conception."
Originally Posted by backseatchris
Should we ever find intelligent life on another planet, it will be very interesting to study their religion (if they have it).
Originally Posted by backseatchris
What if they could offer all the answers we seek? What if they said "we seeded this universe from another" ?
Originally Posted by WeDriveScions
I but, in the end... with Atheism and Theism.... IT ALL COMES DOWN TO FAITH.
Originally Posted by backseatchris
Space is infinite because of how it is expanding. Our universe is like a balloon. We are a point on this balloon. The balloon is going to keep inflating . Every second more space is "being created" if you want to say that.....but even then thats taking a very dumbed down (and almost incorrect) scientific approach to it all.
While this space is expanding, black holes are eating it up piece by piece. Eventually enough black holes will connect and eat a majority of this balloon.
When these black holes consume enough space, they will be able to catch up to the speed of the expanding universe, and then surpass its speed. Eventually the black holes will reach all the way around this balloon and cover its entire surface. When this happens, the negative space + positive space = 0.
The universe should then "crunch" and deflate back to its original state.
When the black holes have finally reached a point where they are to the smallest amount of anything that anything can be, they literally negate their existance and all of this matter that was being compressed will explode violently (since there is nothing to restrain it). Mathematically this can be infinitely cyclical.
Thats just a crash course right there lol. lets not even go into the multiverse scenario.
While this space is expanding, black holes are eating it up piece by piece. Eventually enough black holes will connect and eat a majority of this balloon.
When these black holes consume enough space, they will be able to catch up to the speed of the expanding universe, and then surpass its speed. Eventually the black holes will reach all the way around this balloon and cover its entire surface. When this happens, the negative space + positive space = 0.
The universe should then "crunch" and deflate back to its original state.
When the black holes have finally reached a point where they are to the smallest amount of anything that anything can be, they literally negate their existance and all of this matter that was being compressed will explode violently (since there is nothing to restrain it). Mathematically this can be infinitely cyclical.
Thats just a crash course right there lol. lets not even go into the multiverse scenario.
Originally Posted by olaHalo
ok, stiil havent answered the question.
where did the FIRST anything come from. before your aliens, alternate universes, and other so called logical theories took place.
you still havent established any beginning to your theories.
where did the FIRST anything come from. before your aliens, alternate universes, and other so called logical theories took place.
you still havent established any beginning to your theories.
Originally Posted by backseatchris
An atheist can provide evidence against many things in modern, established religion. so.
Originally Posted by backseatchris
What i am saying is that anything anyone [says] in this universe about god would have to be completely false. If he is what he is, then he is beyond all conception of man. Not even in death would a human understand.
what do mean by "if he is what he is." there are so many interpretations of God or a god. which one do you mean? the only one that matters is the true God. and He explains how we unable to understand Him fully, but not "beyond all conception."
To be atheist requires much more faith than to not. If you can believe that everything came from absolutely nothing, then you've got to have more faith than anyone who believes otherwise.
Originally Posted by Skeorx13
Like I explained before, atheists do not believe everything came from nothing. That is the christian idea. My explanation of the big bang and quantum singularities explained this already.
there is no other way to explain it in your terms. first there was nothing, then there was something, this step is never explained. why?
im sorry but i have not been following this thread from the beginning. just pop in every now and then to put in my 2 cents; can you tell me or at least summarize your quantum singularities and big bang theories? thanks
Originally Posted by olaHalo
Originally Posted by Skeorx13
Like I explained before, atheists do not believe everything came from nothing. That is the christian idea. My explanation of the big bang and quantum singularities explained this already.
there is no other way to explain it in your terms. first there was nothing, then there was something, this step is never explained. why?
im sorry but i have not been following this thread from the beginning. just pop in every now and then to put in my 2 cents; can you tell me or at least summarize your quantum singularities and big bang theories? thanks
Let's look at a couple of things here...
1) Suppose there were no God...where do things like morals come from?...and the idea that there is a God? Just think about it...wouldn't EvErYoNe be running around killing each other and whatnot???
2) For those of you who are atheist and want to look at it from a less religious standpoint...........We know about things that happened in the past because things were written down or passed by mouth from generation to generation....we can go to history class and learn exactly what happened hundreds and even thousands of years ago. So if we know about all this stuff that happened so long ago, how come there is no historical evidence or documentation that we came from monkeys or whatever??? There is one book that goes all the way back to the beginning, it's called the Bible...and it goes to the very beginning...and it says we have a God. So to the atheists out there: Where's your book?
3) If there is no God, then where do we get the idea of God from? It would seem that the idea of a higher power wouldn't even exist if there were no higher power. It had to be placed there somehow.
1) Suppose there were no God...where do things like morals come from?...and the idea that there is a God? Just think about it...wouldn't EvErYoNe be running around killing each other and whatnot???
2) For those of you who are atheist and want to look at it from a less religious standpoint...........We know about things that happened in the past because things were written down or passed by mouth from generation to generation....we can go to history class and learn exactly what happened hundreds and even thousands of years ago. So if we know about all this stuff that happened so long ago, how come there is no historical evidence or documentation that we came from monkeys or whatever??? There is one book that goes all the way back to the beginning, it's called the Bible...and it goes to the very beginning...and it says we have a God. So to the atheists out there: Where's your book?
3) If there is no God, then where do we get the idea of God from? It would seem that the idea of a higher power wouldn't even exist if there were no higher power. It had to be placed there somehow.
Oh...and two other little bits.
Atheists haven't got any more evidence that they are right in their belief than anyone else with some sort of religion. In case you haven't noticed, atheists believe in the "theory" of evolution. Key word "theory" which means that it hasn't been proven yet.
And for my final point for tonight...if we came from monkeys through a process of evolution, then how come the monkeys are still here??? And since they're still here, how come they aren't evolving into humans themselves???
Atheists haven't got any more evidence that they are right in their belief than anyone else with some sort of religion. In case you haven't noticed, atheists believe in the "theory" of evolution. Key word "theory" which means that it hasn't been proven yet.
And for my final point for tonight...if we came from monkeys through a process of evolution, then how come the monkeys are still here??? And since they're still here, how come they aren't evolving into humans themselves???
Originally Posted by SCIONshane
Let's look at a couple of things here...
1) Suppose there were no God...where do things like morals come from?...and the idea that there is a God? Just think about it...wouldn't EvErYoNe be running around killing each other and whatnot???
1) Suppose there were no God...where do things like morals come from?...and the idea that there is a God? Just think about it...wouldn't EvErYoNe be running around killing each other and whatnot???
And the way you're talking, you're saying that no one that believe in god does anything wrong. Apparently the bible doesn't say that taking advantage of little boys is wrong huh.
Originally Posted by SCIONshane
2) For those of you who are atheist and want to look at it from a less religious standpoint...........We know about things that happened in the past because things were written down or passed by mouth from generation to generation....we can go to history class and learn exactly what happened hundreds and even thousands of years ago. So if we know about all this stuff that happened so long ago, how come there is no historical evidence or documentation that we came from monkeys or whatever??? There is one book that goes all the way back to the beginning, it's called the Bible...and it goes to the very beginning...and it says we have a God. So to the atheists out there: Where's your book?
http://www.amazon.com/Portable-Athei...9079422&sr=8-1
And this is the weakest argument I've ever heard.
Originally Posted by SCIONshane
3) If there is no God, then where do we get the idea of God from? It would seem that the idea of a higher power wouldn't even exist if there were no higher power. It had to be placed there somehow.
Originally Posted by SCIONshane
Oh...and two other little bits.
Atheists haven't got any more evidence that they are right in their belief than anyone else with some sort of religion. In case you haven't noticed, atheists believe in the "theory" of evolution. Key word "theory" which means that it hasn't been proven yet.
And for my final point for tonight...if we came from monkeys through a process of evolution, then how come the monkeys are still here??? And since they're still here, how come they aren't evolving into humans themselves???
Atheists haven't got any more evidence that they are right in their belief than anyone else with some sort of religion. In case you haven't noticed, atheists believe in the "theory" of evolution. Key word "theory" which means that it hasn't been proven yet.
And for my final point for tonight...if we came from monkeys through a process of evolution, then how come the monkeys are still here??? And since they're still here, how come they aren't evolving into humans themselves???
One thing I've always wondered is that, isn't everyone an atheist. As defined by dictionary.com, an atheist is:
a person who denies or disbelieves the existence of a supreme being or beings.
How is it that this thread wasn't touched from April 27th to December 29th. Oh I know, DIVINE INTERVENTION!
Just kidding.
Seriously though, thats really bringing a thread back from the dead. Sort of like RESSURRECTION if you will!
Just kidding! Again. I couldn't help myself.
Just kidding.
Seriously though, thats really bringing a thread back from the dead. Sort of like RESSURRECTION if you will!
Just kidding! Again. I couldn't help myself.
Here's a couple atheist quotes I really like:
"When you understand why you dismiss all the other possible gods, you will understand why I dismiss yours."
"I contend that we are both atheists, I just believe in one less god than you"
"When you understand why you dismiss all the other possible gods, you will understand why I dismiss yours."
"I contend that we are both atheists, I just believe in one less god than you"
ih8civx Posted: 1/3/08 10:15AM
I like beer... I like boobes... I love God & his boy Jesus.
Thats all I really wanted to add to this conversation
I like beer... I like boobes... I love God & his boy Jesus.
Thats all I really wanted to add to this conversation
I like that, making a point without being pushy.
Speaking of which, I believe. If you do, fine. If you don't, fine. I really don't care personally.


