If the glass is broken.. you can try car-part.com, but they arent easy to find in salvage. Your next best bet is McGeorges. I got my second one there for $129 after the dealers decided to start gouging people for $180 or more per lamp (Toyota lists them for even less than McGeorges, the dealers mark them up 100% or more). So try car-part.com first, then http://www.mcgeorgeparts.com/MC-BJBB-CE.aspx

Make sure you get the correct side, they are different.

 

is there any secret to popping the lights out? I've been pushing on mine pretty hard and they won't come out.

 

You have to pry a plastic tab back slightly on one side. You should be able to see what I mean by looking up behind the lights with the splash gaurds out.

 

got it.

Don't even waste your time trying to do it by reaching down from on top.

 

Oh hell no... that doesnt work I know some have done it, but my arms dont make it that far down (at least not keeping the skin on them) from the top. Splash gaurds are easy to remove, and make the job easy!