Saab 9-2 vs Scion tC (via GM's discount plan)
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally Posted by jmiller20874
Man GM has really gotten desparate, offering employee discounts for everyone. What do the employee's get?
Originally Posted by turtle
Total $29,595 subtract the $6,000 GM discount and you still have $23,595. With taxes and fees it's about $25,500. That's about $6,500 more than the total charge of a stock TC automatic after all taxes and fees. I'm not going into denial. The Saab is the nicer car, but $6,500 for most tC owner's is more than a third of their total cost and just not affordable.
I'd much rather compare the Linear with the tC, because with the incentive the costs would be similar. But the way the GM special is setup is that you have to take it from dealer stock. Try finding a stock Linear with no options. There aren't any.
Kinda off topic. I am never getting another car with a turbo again. I've owned a 00 Audi A4 1.8t Quattro purchased new and it was the biggest piece of crap on wheels. It was in the shop every week. New transmission, suspension, brake system, turbo, control arms, gaskets, etc. in less than 2 years. Thankfully, dealer service and warranty were great and was done at no cost. I've noticed the same friendly comprehensive (and free) service at Mercedes and BMW, but they kinda have to be with all the problems they have. (i've even had my brake pads and console items replaced for free) Toyota has the worst service. Everyone is mean and they lie through their teeth. (ie. yea sure there's a problem, but i can't do anything about it) But thankfully you won't have to go very often, cuz the cars are bulletproof. So if Saab is anything like the German dealers, then it will only cost you more in terms of time and sanity.
I'd much rather compare the Linear with the tC, because with the incentive the costs would be similar. But the way the GM special is setup is that you have to take it from dealer stock. Try finding a stock Linear with no options. There aren't any.
Kinda off topic. I am never getting another car with a turbo again. I've owned a 00 Audi A4 1.8t Quattro purchased new and it was the biggest piece of crap on wheels. It was in the shop every week. New transmission, suspension, brake system, turbo, control arms, gaskets, etc. in less than 2 years. Thankfully, dealer service and warranty were great and was done at no cost. I've noticed the same friendly comprehensive (and free) service at Mercedes and BMW, but they kinda have to be with all the problems they have. (i've even had my brake pads and console items replaced for free) Toyota has the worst service. Everyone is mean and they lie through their teeth. (ie. yea sure there's a problem, but i can't do anything about it) But thankfully you won't have to go very often, cuz the cars are bulletproof. So if Saab is anything like the German dealers, then it will only cost you more in terms of time and sanity.
On the other hand the Saab 9-5 has "above average" reliability and is "recommended" by consumer reports. Other european brands are a little different : Volkwagen/Audi had overall poor reliability, but BMW had average. Also, BMW and Mercedes has VERY LOW depreciation, mostly because people see them as status symbols and even though most people can't afford a new one, they want to get a used one to show off their precievd status.
Of course, all this doesn't apply to the 9-2X because it's really a Subaru Impreza and has BULLETPROOF reliability, high owner satisfaction, and is a consumer reports "top pick". It is 100% made by Subaru in Japan and has no european parts in it.
And to the people who quote MSRP - I guess you live under a rock cause everyone knows GM is giving employee discount to everyone, on top of the rebates, so the real price for 9-2X Aero is $19500 and $16800 for base Linear (=tC).
I just feel bad for GM car owners that bought a month before GM announced this. Also, I feel bad that their car equity and retail value just plummited. Talk about never buying from a manufacturer again. If that happened to me, I'd never consider GM again.
It's about keeping your existing customer base happy, not always focusing on getting more. Satisfying your exsisting and repeat customers it what will make a company successful. Tisk tisk at GM, bravo for Toyota.
Car deals are one thing. But I'm PROUD to have my hands on something from such a remarkable company.
It's about keeping your existing customer base happy, not always focusing on getting more. Satisfying your exsisting and repeat customers it what will make a company successful. Tisk tisk at GM, bravo for Toyota.
Car deals are one thing. But I'm PROUD to have my hands on something from such a remarkable company.
GM is taking the wrong approach in my opinion. Instead of selling the latest version of the tahoe, grand am, and cavalier at the lowest price.. they need to actually use some of that innovation they do use on the caddy now and then and come out with something new.
yeah, they put every development resource into escalades, hummers, and how many versions of the denali they can make as opposed to developing new CARS. I mean, they just updated the CAVALIER... and the cobalt aint even that hot. Who the hell wants an impala or aveo when you can do so much better for a LITTLE more money. GM, it aint all a money issue with us consumers. First, build a car we WANT to drive, then let's talk price
it's no secret that the real problem with GM is that their current car lineup is mediocre and they can't seem to come up with new cars which surpass the competition. Maybe they should just buy some japanses car company like Subaru who knows how to make really good cars.
Originally Posted by user1234
it's no secret that the real problem with GM is that their current car lineup is mediocre and they can't seem to come up with new cars which surpass the competition. Maybe they should just buy some japanses car company like Subaru who knows how to make really good cars.
Originally Posted by RedheadedStepChild
Originally Posted by user1234
it's no secret that the real problem with GM is that their current car lineup is mediocre and they can't seem to come up with new cars which surpass the competition. Maybe they should just buy some japanses car company like Subaru who knows how to make really good cars.
they have rested on the profits from the giant trucks for far too long. Now that gas prices are going up and truck demand is in decline they have a problem. And what would happen if the japs with start getting into the large truck category ?
Originally Posted by Joe@Dezod
I just feel bad for GM car owners that bought a month before GM announced this. Also, I feel bad that their car equity and retail value just plummited. Talk about never buying from a manufacturer again. If that happened to me, I'd never consider GM again.
Besides, GM was already offering immense rebates, finance subsidies and other discounts that just didn't stand out from the crowded competition. The "employee discount" thing was an attempt to simplify and unify its consumer pricing structure, and to distinguish itself from competitors.
My curiousity is about what happens after the current promotion expires. I think/hope that eventually GM's MSRP pricing will be much closer to selling prices, but I am afraid that the GM empire will continue to hemorrhage cash faster than it can reduce costs. In a couple-odd years, GM owners may face the prospect of driving "orphan cars" whose parts and support are no longer guaranteed by their manufacturer.
The $500 maintenance plan for 46k miles makes no economic sense. I've read the maintenance manual and all they do at scheduled stops is basically change the oil and inspect the car. Inspecting can easily be done yourself; it's called driving.
If you get oil changes every 5000 miles for 46000 miles that is 9.2 oil changes. The first three are free, so make that 6.2 oil changes you're paying for.
6.2 x ($29.99 + $5.00) (sales tax/disposal fees/etc.) comes out to $217, which is $283 less than the maintenance plan.
If you get oil changes every 5000 miles for 46000 miles that is 9.2 oil changes. The first three are free, so make that 6.2 oil changes you're paying for.
6.2 x ($29.99 + $5.00) (sales tax/disposal fees/etc.) comes out to $217, which is $283 less than the maintenance plan.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
scionlife
Exclusive Sponsored Sales
1
May 4, 2017 07:13 AM







