Atheist vs Theist (Debate)
Originally Posted by seattledave
Originally Posted by tCTaco
Originally Posted by citizen01
Phew... back on track.
But seriously, answer my question about why God would make us need to eat if he designed us. Why wouldn't he solve the problem of innocent babies dying of malnurishment by simply making it not necessary to eat. The only reason there could be is he wanted us to sufer. Personally I don't worship Gods that kill innocent babies.
But seriously, answer my question about why God would make us need to eat if he designed us. Why wouldn't he solve the problem of innocent babies dying of malnurishment by simply making it not necessary to eat. The only reason there could be is he wanted us to sufer. Personally I don't worship Gods that kill innocent babies.
I got into an argument with my GF about something similar. We were talking about being stuck in limbo.......and the whole thing that if you're not baptized as a baby and die....that you are stuck in limbo...No heaven or Hell....I called BS, and said thats why I dont follow the churches beliefs......How is GOD, going to turn away one of its creatures because the parents didnt take the time to get the child baptized....she sees my reaction to the beliefs of the church and understands were Im coming from.
Originally Posted by tCTaco
Originally Posted by seattledave
Originally Posted by tCTaco
Originally Posted by citizen01
Phew... back on track.
But seriously, answer my question about why God would make us need to eat if he designed us. Why wouldn't he solve the problem of innocent babies dying of malnurishment by simply making it not necessary to eat. The only reason there could be is he wanted us to sufer. Personally I don't worship Gods that kill innocent babies.
But seriously, answer my question about why God would make us need to eat if he designed us. Why wouldn't he solve the problem of innocent babies dying of malnurishment by simply making it not necessary to eat. The only reason there could be is he wanted us to sufer. Personally I don't worship Gods that kill innocent babies.
I got into an argument with my GF about something similar. We were talking about being stuck in limbo.......and the whole thing that if you're not baptized as a baby and die....that you are stuck in limbo...No heaven or Hell....I called BS, and said thats why I dont follow the churches beliefs......How is GOD, going to turn away one of its creatures because the parents didnt take the time to get the child baptized....she sees my reaction to the beliefs of the church and understands were Im coming from.
Originally Posted by backseatchris
come on guys, we all know the devil was the good guy.
He wanted us to think for ourselves.
he wanted us to give in to temptation (do what WE want)
plus he invented iPods
He wanted us to think for ourselves.
he wanted us to give in to temptation (do what WE want)
plus he invented iPods
ok, tc and everyone else who does the take a religion and strip it down to what you want.
Ok, say I believe in pink unicorns as creators of the universe.
Let's say the idea of pink unicorns creating the universe was written in John smith in the 1901, book, "the pink unicorn".
The book "the pink unicorn" is the only book to claim pink unicorns created the universe.
But I think the book "the pink unicorn" is rubbish, and it has many rules that I am supposed to follow to be part of that religion, that I want nothing to do with.
So why would I still believe pink unicorns as creators of the universe? I mean don't believe in the source material, nor do i follow the religious guidelines.
make sense? Believeing in something that holds no merit even to me, is ridiculous, isn't it?
Ok, say I believe in pink unicorns as creators of the universe.
Let's say the idea of pink unicorns creating the universe was written in John smith in the 1901, book, "the pink unicorn".
The book "the pink unicorn" is the only book to claim pink unicorns created the universe.
But I think the book "the pink unicorn" is rubbish, and it has many rules that I am supposed to follow to be part of that religion, that I want nothing to do with.
So why would I still believe pink unicorns as creators of the universe? I mean don't believe in the source material, nor do i follow the religious guidelines.
make sense? Believeing in something that holds no merit even to me, is ridiculous, isn't it?
tcTaco, I know what you mean. I was an Agnostic for quite a few years mainly because I followed your line of thinking.
I was raised Catholic (ie TOLD what to believe) and then rebelled against that when I got old enough to realize what I was doing. I couldn't understand how some people thought one BOOK was better then someone elses.
So I spent a few years as an agnostic, then I found out about some eastern religions that believed that all religions were right, and no one person had a monopoly on the Truth. So I was a New Age-ish "free thinking" spiritual person for the next few years.
Then I came to realize I was making a religion up in my head that makes me feel good and that I could use to make the world easier for me. Of course I had to smack myself after that, I was being no better then the people that say there is no God just so they could do whatever they want without feeling any form of guilt.
Which pretty much brought me to the point that I am at today.
I was raised Catholic (ie TOLD what to believe) and then rebelled against that when I got old enough to realize what I was doing. I couldn't understand how some people thought one BOOK was better then someone elses.
So I spent a few years as an agnostic, then I found out about some eastern religions that believed that all religions were right, and no one person had a monopoly on the Truth. So I was a New Age-ish "free thinking" spiritual person for the next few years.
Then I came to realize I was making a religion up in my head that makes me feel good and that I could use to make the world easier for me. Of course I had to smack myself after that, I was being no better then the people that say there is no God just so they could do whatever they want without feeling any form of guilt.
Which pretty much brought me to the point that I am at today.
I think budists are taught not to degrade anyone elses religion...which I think is great and polite. I was never brought up believing anything, so I think that's why I don't have a religion that I truly believe in. I'm open to anyone's religion and I don't discriminate.
I'm kind of at the point where I think if you believe in something hard enough...it will become true. I think that can be applied to pretty much everday life, with reason. Therefore, I believe whatever culture believes in their religion enough...it is true.
...Don't anyone take offense to this now...
oh, and what taco was saying about no believing in one denomination over the other...I kinda feel the same. Who's to say their right and everyone else is wrong when the bible is merely based on faith? Wars were carried out in god's name over who's denomination what right or wrong...would god really want that?
I'm kind of at the point where I think if you believe in something hard enough...it will become true. I think that can be applied to pretty much everday life, with reason. Therefore, I believe whatever culture believes in their religion enough...it is true.
...Don't anyone take offense to this now...
oh, and what taco was saying about no believing in one denomination over the other...I kinda feel the same. Who's to say their right and everyone else is wrong when the bible is merely based on faith? Wars were carried out in god's name over who's denomination what right or wrong...would god really want that?
Originally Posted by KahunaBlair
Of course I had to smack myself after that, I was being no better then the people that say there is no God just so they could do whatever they want without feeling any form of guilt.
I know I can't get some magic resolve that repenting/praying does.
Originally Posted by Tito_Cruz
I think budists are taught not to degrade anyone elses religion...which I think is great and polite. I was never brought up believing anything, so I think that's why I don't have a religion that I truly believe in. I'm open to anyone's religion and I don't discriminate.
I'm kind of at the point where I think if you believe in something hard enough...it will become true. I think that can be applied to pretty much everday life, with reason. Therefore, I believe whatever culture believes in their religion enough...it is true.
...Don't anyone take offense to this now...
I'm kind of at the point where I think if you believe in something hard enough...it will become true. I think that can be applied to pretty much everday life, with reason. Therefore, I believe whatever culture believes in their religion enough...it is true.
...Don't anyone take offense to this now...
Originally Posted by Tito_Cruz
oh, and what taco was saying about no believing in one denomination over the other...I kinda feel the same. Who's to say their right and everyone else is wrong when the bible is merely based on faith? Wars were carried out in god's name over who's denomination what right or wrong...would god really want that?
Originally Posted by seattledave
Originally Posted by KahunaBlair
Of course I had to smack myself after that, I was being no better then the people that say there is no God just so they could do whatever they want without feeling any form of guilt.
I know I can't get some magic resolve that repenting/praying does.
That being said, if you were to talk to someone that was a true Christian and not just a stupid bible qouting parrot, I'd think you'd be suprised to see that we don't get to escape guilt. We just have another "Person" to answer to besides ourselves when we do something wrong.





